Advanced R &D, Inc.


 

 

 

 

 

A Paradox

Advanced R & D has long been recognized as a leader in Surface Chemistry and methods and technology involving CLEANING Surfaces. This has lead to an understanding of products designed for cleaning many materials under most conditions. It has also lead to understanding CORROSION and special products designed to prevent corrosion. This brief discussion provides a clearer understanding of the importance and role of cleaning; what to look for in cleaning products, HOW , WHEN, and WHERE they might be applied and what considerations are important.:

To Understand CORROSION one must understand cleaning.

To Understand CLEANING one must understand contamination.

To understand CONTAMINATION one must understand surfaces.

To understand SURFACES one must understand Surface Chemistry.

What is a SURFACE ?

"SURFACE" is a vague and ambiguous term but it is WHERE corrosion begins. "SURFACE" is more explicitly described using the following illustration. In industrial applications, the term "Surface" is not merely a flat two dimensional plane as in mathematics. To properly understand Surface Chemistry, Contamination, Corrosion, and Cleaning, the term "SURFACE" must imply a degree of thickness, often on a very microscopic scale; or molecular level. Although surface roughness and physical shape etc. have effects, almost all initial interactions begin at the atomic ( molecular ) scale. This chemistry dictates the performance of the surface, corrosion, adhesion, friction, reactivity, etc. Macro features including surface roughness, texture, shape, pits, cracks, scratches, etc. have a more general effect in collection of debris, retention of contaminants, formation of electrochemical centers, and abrasion.

This Figure of a "Typical Surface" illustrates the four major layers found on virtually every solid surface. The chemical composition of the "Surface" is always different than the chemistry of the substrate or bulk material. The bulk material may be steel, Aluminum, brass, zinc, polypropylene, polystyrene, etc. but the surface composition is very different than this. These four layers include: 1. A BULK substrate ( such as the metal or polymer), two. A normal OXIDE layer, 3. A Prepared or intentional layer, and 4. A very outer layer that is generally unknown and not easily controlled. This outer layer is usually very rich in contaminants. On top of this contaminant layer may be additional material, such as air, water, and organic material that is not chemically attached but may eventually react. The thickness of each layer is as important as its composition.

These two figures illustrate the contaminants that can be found on normal 'clean ' steel. The one on the left illustrates ISS depth profile spectra showing changes in chemical composition vs. depth. The figure on the right illustrates how these data can be used to construct an approximation of the distribution of various elements in this the outer layers of a surface; each row representing one or two atomic layers.

For many metals, such as steel, the oxide layer is about 40 to 60 Angstroms thick ( about 1/6 of one microinch; about 1/200th of a micron, or about 20 to 30 layers of atoms). The contamination layer may be less than a complete atomic or molecular layer or several mils thick ( more than 0.001" ). Often contaminant layers cannot be observed visually or they may be very thin and cause unusual discoloration.

Advanced R & D laboratory has used very sensitive and sophisticated instrumental techniques to analyze surface chemistry of wide range of materials for over 20 years. More extensive explanation of these techniques is available upon request. Through these analyses, Advanced R & D has provided much better understanding about surface chemistry and how it affects Corrosion, Contamination, Cleaning, and Adhesion. Many companies have used this information to solve industrial manufacturing problems and to improve their own products.

What is SURFACE CONTAMINATION ?

The term "Contamination" is also misleading. What is considered extremely gross contamination in one case may be impossible to see visually. Conversely, what appears by eye to be very crude contamination may have no measurable effect on product performance. Yet, Surface Contamination is a major cause for corrosion, but sometimes it may actually prevent corrosion.

For simplicity, we consider contamination to be the presence of any material that is not intentional or planned. To properly assess its effects, all of the following factors must be considered:

................. Chemical Type Physical Type

................. Concentration Thickness

................. Distribution Product Application

In general, it takes only a very thin layer of contamination of the right type at the right concentration to initiate corrosion, prevent adhesion, or cause discoloration. Very sophisticated surface analysis techniques have been used in pioneering the development of corrosion inhibitors and cleaning products. Advanced R & D has provided much of this information. There are four major analytical instrumental techniques commonly considered applicable to analysis of these thin outer surface layers. They include ISS ( Ion Scattering Spectroscopy ), SIMS ( Secondary Ion Mass Spectroscopy), XPS ( X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy - also termed ESCA ), and AES ( Auger Electron Spectroscopy).

What happens DURING Cleaning of Surfaces?

Product performance depends intimately on surface cleanliness before, during, and after manufacture. Many components require cleaning before preprocessing, at several stages of processing and after final production or assembly. CONTAMINATION and / or CORROSION may start at any stage. The concept and understanding of the term "Cleaning" is often used loosely and vaguely. It is clarified below. Over the past 20 years, we have helped hundreds of companies in hundreds of different applications understand their products, their cleaning requirements, and their operations -- and their Product Failures. The following considerations apply to each product, product change, and company

1. What materials are used in the product and its manufacture?

2. What are the original surface contaminants on the component?

3. What surface contaminants exist prior to surface cleaning at any stage of cleaning?

4. What are processing conditions throughout manufacturing?

5. What chemistry exists throughout processing and manufacturing?

6. **What conditions will the product be exposed to during storage and use?

7. *** What are the requirements for surface cleanliness of the product for final performance?

8. What are the effects of various contaminants on product performance? or Failure?

Some components ( such as machined metals ) may be severely contaminated before cleaning; some ( such as electronic devices and medical implants ) may be extremely clean. Others may have extremely stringent requirements for surface cleanliness after cleaning; some may not be crucial. The same cleaning process in one case may permit use of solutions many times for many batches; other cases may require fresh cleaning solutions for every batch of product. Batch cleaning will surely be different than continuous methods. *** It is extremely difficult to clean large numbers of parts adequately using only a single stage of cleaning. We very strongly recommend at least a two-stage operation, especially a final rinse containing a corrosion inhibitor.

A cleaning solution may not completely remove all contaminants from severely contaminated components or the contaminant may severely contaminate the cleaning solution. Likewise, when a product is very clean to begin with, the solution may be more effective and remain free of dissolved contaminants for much longer use. All contaminants are not necessarily removed form the parts being cleaned and some chemical components and contaminants in the cleaning solution may redeposit on the surface of the parts. The rates at which these reactions occur are dependent on the chemical nature of the parts and the processing conditions such as Temperature, Time, Concentrations, Agitation, Volumes, etc.

***** The FINAL STAGE of cleaning is extremely important and depends on the procedures, not just the products used by the manufacturers. As a part is removed from a solution, contaminants within the solutions may redeposit very rapidly on the parts thus reversing all efforts to remove contaminants. Even very brief exposure to air can form compounds ( from very rapid air oxidation ) that are not readily soluble in normal cleaners. Thus, immediate removal of residual cleaning solutions is very important. This may be done by immediate treatment with a second solution of water or clean compressed air. Some metals, especially cast iron and steel, corrode extremely rapidly at this stage. For some metals, the cleaner the surface the faster the initial corrosion ! ( flash rusting ). But, if the surface is not properly cleaned, severe corrosion or product failure, such as adhesive failure, may result later at greater expense. Corrosion Inhibitors should be used at this stage.

WHEN do I use a Cleaner ?

One major mistake made in industrial processing is to start cleaning a product too late in manufacturing. Contaminants which could be eliminated from incoming supplies and raw goods are carried all the way to the final product completion. Cleaners and corrosion inhibitors should be used at the first possible stage of manufacturing and throughout each stage wherever possible. Fortunately, some cleaner's Advanced R & D has helped develop, contain built-in corrosion inhibitors.

How do I SELECT a Cleaning Product ? 

Advanced R & D can provide cleaners for nearly every application involving most metals; iron, copper, zinc, brass, stainless steel, silver, solders, electronics, rust removers, and others. Based on years of experience in analysis of coatings and adhesive failures, Advanced R & D has found that poor surface cleaning is the major cause of product failure. Hence, effective cleaning and corrosion inhibitors must be used immediately after or even during cleaning. And, the correct cleaner and correct concentration must be used. As an independent consulting firm, Advanced R & D can provide recommendations and professional guidance in this selection.

The chemical nature of contaminants on the surface dictates the requirements of the cleaner. Most organic materials can be cleaned easily with less aggressive cleaners although highly degraded organic material is extremely insoluble. Inorganic contaminants oftener require very aggressive cleaning and may even need conditions that are too harsh for practical use due to safety, toxicity, and environmental requirements. They may actually require physical cleaning. Most cleaners recommended or supplied by Advanced R & D are nonhazardous, environmental friendly, biodegradable, nitrite free, non-corrosive, and free of noxious solvents, trichloroethylene, methylene chloride, CFC's, or flammable solvents.

 

What are the Important "RULES TO REMEMBER" about CLEANING?

 

The practical " RULES " of surface cleaning are summarized below. However, each and every product and its individual components should be carefully evaluated regarding its original contaminants and final requirements. Advanced R & D has done this type of evaluation for many companies for many years.

 

1.

ALL  surfaces are  contaminated.
 - - - - - t is the Amount, Type, and Thickness of contamination you are concerned about.

2.

One cannot merely " clean " any surface.

 - - - - - - You must know what you are doing.

3.

A particular cleaner will not clean ALL surfaces.

- - - - - - An appropriate cleaner and procedure must be chosen.

4. 

All cleaned surface will automatically get recontaminated.

This is due to natural, thermodynamic driving forces.

This type of contamination may be 'controllable'.

5.

 It will COST $$$ to clean a surface properly and reliably.

6.

It will COST many, many more $$$$$$ if it is not done properly.

7. 

Use Advanced R & D for evaluations, recommendations, selection of cleaners, and corrosion inhibitors can save many $$$$$.


Home ]

Send mail to AdvancedRD@aol.com with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2000 Advanced R&D, written by Dr. Gene R. Sparrow
Last modified: Dec 11, 2008